Between the two, I'd pick the JW.......it's beautiful, and always seems to be a notch above.
Whenever we've stayed at a JW, and we have at least 4 times in major cities like San Francisco, Washington DC, Orlando, & Atlanta,
we've loved them.
For a better deal, you might also consider these:
We stayed once in New Orleans at the
Renaissance Pere Marquette 8-10 years ago and loved it, especially the concierge lounge,
so good we had lunch there every day.
Short walk to Canal St, Bourbon St, Royal St.
Plan a stay at our 4-star hotel on Common Street, New Orleans. Discover the spacious and stylish rooms in a superb location at the Renaissance New Orleans Pere Marquette French Quarter Area Hotel.
www.marriott.com
There's also the
The Saint Hotel/Autograph Collection (fabulous)!
The Saint looks wonderful. If going today, if not the JW Marriott, I'd probably consider that one. We like that brand a lot.
https://www.marriott.com/hotels/travel/msyak-the-saint-hotel-autograph-collection/
also, the N.O. Westin Hotel/French QTR...lots of good choices.
Googlemaps Locations:
goo.gl