Check out the reviews on the two resorts. We've not stayed in either but anyy place on the island would satisfy me. We have just returned from a walk on the beach. The weather was in 70's with bright blue skies today. You can access most of the plantations by playing golf, going to restaurants within the gates, etc. Sea Pines does require a $5 fee per car to enter but a visit to Harbor Town and the ride through Sea Pines is worth the money. You need to be able to create your own entertainment on HHI. It is not your normal beach town. There is a lot to do in a week, but relaxation is the key. There are wonderful restaurants, good shopping, golf, tennis, biking, walking on the beach, good theatre productions depending on time of your visit. Savannah is a good day trip as are Beaufort and Old Town Bluffton. You could always visit Sun City and maybe even run into a Tugger!! We are so fortunate to live near HHI and hope you come down and have a wonderful visit to the low country.