Whichever you choose, just be sure to use the HE detergent and use about half of what they suggest- especially if you have soft water.
Jim Ricks
There are some old threads in the lounge discussing both top-loading washers and the amounts of detergent to use. Interested readers can use the search feature to call them up.
Even one-half the suggested amount is often overkill. I use closer to one-fifth the recommended amount with no problem.
****
If you or a member of your family is sensitive to detergent in clothes, think about that for a moment. What that means is that when you are finished laundering your clothes, there is still detergent residue in your clothes.
IOW - you used too much detergent!!! You had so much free detergent inside the washer that it didn't all rinse out of your clothes. Cut back on the amount of detergent you are using by 50%; you will have less detergent residue remaining in your clothes and I bet your clothes will almost surely come out just as clean. If you're still having significant detergent residue, cut your detergent usage in half again. Do that a third time or a fourth time.
Even if you don't have detergent sensitivities, you can still follow the same approach for investigating how much detergent you need. Just keep cutting back on the amount of detergent you use until you notice a change in cleaning effectiveness. Then go back up one level. If you try that most users will find they can easily cut back their detergent by at least 75%, and many will find that they can get by with only 10% of what they have been using.
BTW - I'm talking about actual detergent residue in the clothes (typically causing itchiness), not the detergent perfurme. The perfumes are formulated to remain in the clothes, so cutting back on detergent will almost never get the perfume smell out of the clothes if you used a detergent containing perfumes.