Considering these cars are driven by hundreds, if not thousands of people over their life as a rental, plus the though that renters might not drive them as carefully as they would their own car, it would have to be a really steep discount before I’d even consider buying a rental. I have my doubts routines maintenance is even done very well on these cars. Somehow I can’t see a corporation putting a cent more into their inventory than is absolutely necessary. Because everything is done in house, it would be difficult to determine the exact history of the car, including accidents and repairs. Carfax relies heavily on insurance claims to gather their information and, if the repairs are done in-house, nobodies going to know.
We were in Kauai when I inadvertently high centered the rental. I was looking the situation over to try to either avoid damaging the car or minimizing damage when a couple of surfer dudes walked up. One asked, “Is it a rental?” When I said yes his answer was, “Well just blaze in dude!” Thus is the opinion of enough renters I’d be skeptical of buying a rental car after it’s been driven 60,000 or 70,000 miles.