Hotel Hana
I have never stayed there and probably never will... I've been spoiled by timeshare values.
BUT! Hana Hotel is a genuine Hawaiian charmer. During my visit to Hana last January, I had to make a stop because I enjoyed watching a Travel Channel Hotel Hana feature. I am glad I did. The hotel's greatest feature is the cluster of cabins along the shore. I took a self-guided, unauthorized walk throughout the grounds and thought it would make a great timeshare
I doubt there is any other lodging establishment in Hana that could come close. The high prices are a result of the extremely rare charm, not because of the luxury. Although I did not see the inside of the cabins, I doubt they are priced because of their extravagance. They are on the primitive side... they are cabins, yet well maintained. I would always rather have perfect charm over extravagance.
Another place that holds similar charm is the Hanalei Colony Resort on Kauai. I was pleased to see they were remodeling some of their cabins during my last visit to Kauai. I would love to see Hanalei Colony Resort reach the same acclaim and standards of Hotel Hana. One of my outlandish dreams... that I never expect to realize... is to one day own the Hanalei Colony Resort and strive to raise it to become the "Star of Kuai Lodging." It will never make it there by trying to become the most extravagant, but could easily make it by sprucing up its natural charm... quaint, well maintained cabins along the Kauai coast surrounded by lush tropical gardens! Even the dream of being a live-in hotel manager/owner of such a place brings a delight. The hard work would be continuing pleasure!
Now, if you reconsider staying at Hotel Hana, don't waste the opportunity by staying in the hotel proper... spring for one of the coastal cabins. If you can't imagine the price being worth it, consider the Hanalei Colony Resort for a future stay for about half the price. The Hanalei Colony Resort has even more potential, in my opinion, because the cabins are closer to the shore than the ones in Hana and the surrounding area is even more picturesque than Hana. (The last statement is not a comment on a "Road to Hana" trip... I consider it "The Best of Maui," just a comparison of the immediate areas surrounding the two resorts.)