• The TUGBBS forums are completely free and open to the public and exist as the absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 29 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other Owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered!
  • TUG started 30 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Check out our happy birthday post here: Happy Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    Come check it out for a chance to win a Free TUG membership (or renewal) just for helping out!

    Read more here
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $21,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $21 Million dollars
  • Follow the TUG Member Banner as it travels the world on vacation with Timeshare owners! Also sign up to get the banner sent to you so you can submit a photo of your vacation with the banner to share with TUG! Banner Thread
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free! 60,000+ subscribers! Latest resort reviews and the most important topics discussed by owners during the week!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    Read more Here
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

Anybody ever had a "Comparative Market Analysis"?

Brerrabbit

newbie
Joined
May 21, 2010
Messages
83
Reaction score
4
Points
168
Location
Park Hills KY
I got a post card from a company called www.timeshareresales.net. I called them up and they said that they were licensed real estate brokers/agents and that the fees and commissions would be added to the sales price and paid by the buyer.

However, this lady told me that I would have to have a "Comparative Market Analysis" so that the buyer would know that they were paying a realistic price for it when they went to get financing, and that I would have to pay $500 or so for this. I am sure she wanted me to get one from someone she was recommending (who would probably give her a kickback of some kind) and was very uncooperative when I asked her to send me the requirements of what this had to contain in order to be acceptable to the lender, so I could get one on my own. As far as I was concerned it was just another scam that they came up with.

I am just curious if anyone else has ever done this or had any experience with this kind of thing.
 

rrlongwell

newbie
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Mechanicsburg, Pa.
I got a post card from a company called www.timeshareresales.net. I called them up and they said that they were licensed real estate brokers/agents and that the fees and commissions would be added to the sales price and paid by the buyer ...

Interesting sales pitch. I would think that is something they could do cheaply and I would also think they would not charge for it.
 

Passepartout

TUG Review Crew: Veteran
TUG Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2007
Messages
28,128
Reaction score
16,678
Points
1,299
Location
Twin Falls, Eye-Duh-Hoe
WOW! I sure wish I could charge $500 to go to eBay, check 'completed auctions' and report that actual, proven, comparative values for (this resort week) were $x or $xx or $xxx.

Even better- send the dough upfront!

Ya gotta love the creativity.

Jim
 

richardm

TUG Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
1,263
Reaction score
36
Points
409
Location
Orlando
It's a scam.. Appraisal scams have been common in timeshare.

Florida law specifically prohibits a licensed real estate broker from charging upfront fees to sell timeshares. This is probably their "method" of trying to skirt the law. If you have documentation to prove your claim that this company is telling you a $500. CMA is required to list your timeshare, file a complaint with the Florida Attorney Generals office at http://myfloridalegal.com/timeshares.

You can get a CMA from any licensed real estate associate. I have prepared hundreds for clients (primarily estate and bankruptcy attorneys) over the years to be used primarily for legal purposes and the most I have ever charged is $59. simply because to be done formally in a proper written form takes time and specific research.

I give sellers informal estimates of value over the phone for free on a daily basis! Any broker worth a damn should be able to give you a realistic expectation of value within a few minutes verbally, and at no charge!

Again- if you have proof, please take the time to file the complaint.. It will take about ten minutes at most and this would appear to be an easy case to prosecute for the state of Florida if what you have said is true..
 

timeos2

Tug Review Crew: Rookie
TUG Lifetime Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2005
Messages
11,183
Reaction score
5
Points
36
Location
Rochester, NY
I got a post card from a company called www.timeshareresales.net. I called them up and they said that they were licensed real estate brokers/agents and that the fees and commissions would be added to the sales price and paid by the buyer.

However, this lady told me that I would have to have a "Comparative Market Analysis" so that the buyer would know that they were paying a realistic price for it when they went to get financing, and that I would have to pay $500 or so for this. I am sure she wanted me to get one from someone she was recommending (who would probably give her a kickback of some kind) and was very uncooperative when I asked her to send me the requirements of what this had to contain in order to be acceptable to the lender, so I could get one on my own. As far as I was concerned it was just another scam that they came up with.

I am just curious if anyone else has ever done this or had any experience with this kind of thing.

Nothing new just a recycle of one of many ways to get an upfront fee for no service that was very prevalent 5-6 years ago. It was shut down then by authorities who correctly surmised that it was just an up front fee in disguise.

Don't pay it and don't try to deal with the group that contacted you or you will likely be out your money and still own your timeshare.
 

ronparise

TUG Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2011
Messages
12,663
Reaction score
2,132
Points
548
We real estae agents do CMA's all the time for free. Its our way of showing a prospective customer what their home is worth, and its also a good way to guide a buyer when they are trying to decide how much to offer for a particular property

I know with regular realestae there is nothing wrong with a realestae agent in Florida charging a fee for their services, instead of or in addition to a percentage based commission. and there is nothing wrong with charging those fees upfront...as long as the service they are providing is actually delivered. For example if I list a piece of property for sale, my deal with the seller may be that the seller pay for all the marketing and advertising fees in addition to a percentage based commission and that they pay for the advertising up front...Pinnacle timeshare here in Fort Myers (they are the only authorized Blue Green points reseller) does that...they charge a $39 advertising fee up front when you list your timeshare with them. and a $2000commission at closing. And its perfectly legal

I dont think charging you $500 for a CMA is illegal, as long as they actually do the work and deliver their opinion to you..However I wouldnt advise that you do it...It is just another way of extracting money from you, with little or no hope that your timeshare will actually get sold
 

ampaholic

TUG Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2010
Messages
2,305
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Location
Spokane
...
I dont think charging you $500 for a CMA is illegal, as long as they actually do the work and deliver their opinion to you..However I wouldnt advise that you do it...It is just another way of extracting money from you, with little or no hope that your timeshare will actually get sold

As a retired Real Estate Broker I would say while charging $500 for a CMA may well be legal (or not) it certainly is overpriced.

I can't see it being worth more than fifty bucks.

I used to drive out to a property for out of state owners, do a CMA, take 6 pictures outside and 12 inside (if available) and fax it to them for $50 to $75 all the time. The $50 to $75 was mainly for car expenses and my time.
 

Rent_Share

TUG Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
5,091
Reaction score
2
Points
473
Location
SOCAL (562)
Just a recycled SCAM upfront fee
 

BocaBum99

TUG Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
6,651
Reaction score
4
Points
323
Location
Boca Raton, FL
I got a post card from a company called www.timeshareresales.net. I called them up and they said that they were licensed real estate brokers/agents and that the fees and commissions would be added to the sales price and paid by the buyer.

However, this lady told me that I would have to have a "Comparative Market Analysis" so that the buyer would know that they were paying a realistic price for it when they went to get financing, and that I would have to pay $500 or so for this. I am sure she wanted me to get one from someone she was recommending (who would probably give her a kickback of some kind) and was very uncooperative when I asked her to send me the requirements of what this had to contain in order to be acceptable to the lender, so I could get one on my own. As far as I was concerned it was just another scam that they came up with.

I am just curious if anyone else has ever done this or had any experience with this kind of thing.

It's totally legal to charge for a CMA. However, it won't give you any useful information.

I'll charge you $250 for a CMA that will be probably as accurate.

If you want to do it yourself, I'll tell you my methodology. If you like it, you can send me $100 for teaching you the method.

Here it is.

Get a dart, throw it at a dart board. Multiply the number hit by $1000. That's your CMA. Try it. It works great.
 

rrlongwell

newbie
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Mechanicsburg, Pa.
WOW! I sure wish I could charge $500 to go to eBay, check 'completed auctions' and report that actual, proven, comparative values for (this resort week) were $x or $xx or $xxx.

Even better- send the dough upfront!

Ya gotta love the creativity.

Jim

Just goes to show you are not a scammer.
 

rrlongwell

newbie
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
2,770
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Mechanicsburg, Pa.
It's totally legal to charge for a CMA. However, it won't give you any useful information.

I'll charge you $250 for a CMA that will be probably as accurate.

If you want to do it yourself, I'll tell you my methodology. If you like it, you can send me $100 for teaching you the method.

Here it is.

Get a dart, throw it at a dart board. Multiply the number hit by $1000. That's your CMA. Try it. It works great.

You forgot the footnote for timeshares. Divide by 0.
 

richardm

TUG Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
1,263
Reaction score
36
Points
409
Location
Orlando
I'm of the opinion that "requiring" any type of fee for service in order to "list" a timeshare with a licensed real estate broker in Florida is in fact illegal...

FS721.20

(6) It is unlawful for any real estate broker, broker associate, or sales associate to collect any advance fee for the listing of any timeshare estate or timeshare license.
(7) It is unlawful for any broker, salesperson, or broker-salesperson to collect any advance fee for the listing of a personal property timeshare interest.

While everything is obviously open to interpretation, I think the intent of this legislation is clearly to prohibit licensed brokers from charging any type of upfront fee. Currently, the Florida Attorney General has her hands full fighting the unlicensed scams- but I'm willing to bet that when she receives a validated complaint proving that a Florida broker is requiring an advance payment in order for a consumer to "list" their timeshare, it will lead to an easy investigation..
 

BocaBum99

TUG Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
6,651
Reaction score
4
Points
323
Location
Boca Raton, FL
I'm of the opinion that "requiring" any type of fee for service in order to "list" a timeshare with a licensed real estate broker in Florida is in fact illegal...

FS721.20

(6) It is unlawful for any real estate broker, broker associate, or sales associate to collect any advance fee for the listing of any timeshare estate or timeshare license.
(7) It is unlawful for any broker, salesperson, or broker-salesperson to collect any advance fee for the listing of a personal property timeshare interest.

While everything is obviously open to interpretation, I think the intent of this legislation is clearly to prohibit licensed brokers from charging any type of upfront fee. Currently, the Florida Attorney General has her hands full fighting the unlicensed scams- but I'm willing to bet that when she receives a validated complaint proving that a Florida broker is requiring an advance payment in order for a consumer to "list" their timeshare, it will lead to an easy investigation..

A broker can charge for a CMA. It's the same as paying for a pet rock. Legal, just not useful.
 

Carolinian

TUG Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
10,530
Reaction score
868
Points
598
Location
eastern Europe
A broker can charge for a CMA. It's the same as paying for a pet rock. Legal, just not useful.

Charging for it may be legal, but making it a condition for listing the timeshare probably is NOT.

Also saying that a CMA is necessary a lender for financing for a buyer is hogwash. Almost no resale timeshare involves financing in the first place. Secondary, if one did, no lender is going to use a CMA to establish value, but to the contrary are going to demand an appraisal, which is a lot more involved and needs a qualified appraiser. Additionally, an appraisal is normally a buyers expense, not a sellers expense.
 
Top