• The TUGBBS forums are completely free and open to the public and exist as the absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 30 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other Owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 30 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 30th anniversary: Happy 30th Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    Free memberships for every 50 subscribers!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $21,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $21 Million dollars
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    60,000+ subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

HOA holding the line against MF increases?

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
I included a link to a real estate agent's website, where she indicates that the 2 bdrm HOA fees are $1858 to $2425 per month. Not sure why you think that that isn't accurate. Anyway, below is a listing for a 1240 sq. foot 2 bdrm/2 bath for sale at Honua Kai right now. (WKORV-N villas are 1230 sq. feet , so as true an apples to apples comparison as I could find.) The MFs for this unit are listed as $2133.

https://search.emauirealestate.com/maui/5-376389/130-KAI-MALINA-PKWY-606-Lahaina



Most of the utilities are covered with the MFs. "...(Honua Kai Maintenance) fee covers the costs for water, rubbish removal, sewer, landscaping, basic cable TV service, maintenance and electricity of all common elements, pest control, security, pool, capital reserves, payroll for the management/admin of the association, and insurance for the property...

Individual owners are responsible for electricity charges, phone/internet services, property taxes, and insurance."

https://www.hawaiirealestatesearch.com/blog/honua-kai-hoa-fees.html

So let's expand utility line to $1000 and it should more than cover phone/internet, homeowner's insurance, and electric:
  • Phone/Internet: Hawaii Telecom's best internet plan is $99.95/month and basic phone is $30/month. https://broadbandnow.com/Hawaiian-Telcom
  • Homeowner's Insurance: Homeowner's insurance in Hawaii is actually pretty low, the average homeowner paying ~$1000 a year so that's $84/month. (Loren Clive, a residential real estate broker indicates in her 2nd posting linked below that she pays $469/year for her 1 bdrm/1 bath rental condo, so $1000 in right in line with that.
https://www.biggerpockets.com/forum...rt-term-rental-occupancy-rates-electric-bills
https://www.reviews.com/homeowners-insurance/hawaii/
  • Electric: That leaves $785/month for electric, which seems reasonable as Loren Clive reported in her first post above that her monthly electric bills for a 1 bdrm/1 bath unit with 1 room a/c was $200-300/mo.
https://www.aimforawesome.com/hawaii/moving-to-hawaii/hawaiis-high-cost-of-living/



Nope. I actually included a link to the Maui County property tax website, where I linked to an actual 2 bdrm 1230 sq foot condo at Honua Kai. The half year taxes on this property are $6052.88x2 = $12,105.76. That is $1008.81 per month.

http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060580



Please expand on this. Here's what I can come up with for a budget for a 5-year cycle. And keep in mind that these are retail prices. WKORV should receive significant volume discounts on just about everything I've listed, including mattresses, furniture, appliances, carpet, tile, curtains, and linens.

600 sq feet of carpet: $5000 - replaced every 5 years $5000
600 sq feet of tile: replaced every 10 years - $13,500 every 10 years or $6750
Painting: Materials and labor: $7300 - every 2.5 years - $14600
Mattress: $3000 x 2 beds - replaced every 5 years = $6000
Couch: $3500 couch and $2000 love seat replaced every 7 years = $5500
Dining table: $2000 replaced every 5 years - $2000
TVs: 42 inch: $600 x 2 - replaced every 5 years - $1200
Sheets, Pillows, comforters = $500 x 2 bdrms replaced every year = $5000
Towels: $200 x 2 bedrooms replaced every year = $400
Curtains: $1000 x 3 exterior windows replaced every 5 years = $3000
Fridge $1000: replaced every 10 years = $500
Fridge (compact): $520 - replaced every 5 years = $520
Stove: $650 - replaced every 10 years = $325
2 burner cooktop: $585 - replaced every 10 years = $292
Dishwasher: $850 - replaced every 5 years = $850
Compact dishwasher: $820 - replaced every 5 years = $820
Microwave $650 - replaced every 5 years = $650 x 2 = $1300
Washer/Dryer combo - $1500 - replaced every 10 years = $750 x 2 = $1500
Misc kitchen ware, irons, blow dryers: $300 - replaced every year = $1500
New granite: $7500 - replaced every 15 years = $2500
Lanai furniture: $500 - replaced every 5 years x 2 = $1000

Grand total.................$60,557

Am I missing anything major here?

Carpet cost: https://www.manta.com/cost-carpet-replacement-kihei-hi
Tile cost: https://www.manta.com/cost-tile-installation-kahului-hi
Painting cost: https://www.manta.com/cost-house-painting-kahului-hi

Furniture was replaced based on this guide: https://www.factotum.co.uk/2017/07/04/furniture-life-span/

Appliance replacement was assisted using this guide: https://www.mrappliance.com/expert-tips/appliance-life-guide/

Appliance costs are based on a middle of the road stainless steel model at Costco plus 30% Hawaii mark-up because I couldn't get my location to switch to Maui.



Front desk operations and security are covered in the $2133/month MFs. Housekeeping is a fair point. I'd add in $800/month for that. And, once again, keep in mind that I wouldn't enjoy the benefit of owning 600 units, which would bring the housekeeping cost down significantly.



It really doesn't matter what you call it because an owner is still on the hook for paying it. We're discussing the REAL cost of ownership vs. what y'all are paying for ownership. But if you insist, I'll revise it to $9200.

Here are my revised figures:

$2133 MFs
$1008 property taxes
$1000 utilities & homeowner's insurance
$1000 Capital Improvements
$800 Housekeeping
-------
$5941 WITHOUT any volume discounts
v. $9200, which is what WKORV is charging you.



What services are you talking about? Spa? Well, I can walk to the one at the Westin! There is an on-site restaurant, Duke's. II membership can be bought for $100/year.

P.S. I've probably have spent more time composing these posts than your friends have spent running the HOA. :)

For the property taxes, you have cherry picked one of the lowest valued 2BR at Honua Kai. The values of 2BR at Honua Kai are in the $1.6-1.7MM range.

Your replacement reserve estimates are still very much understated as are your assumptions on housekeeping costs.

Your HOA figure for Honua Kai is also low and not a true representation of the average blend for 2BR ownerships.

The Honua Kai HOAs most certainly do not include the full property management services an owner would need if renting their unit four weeks out of every month. That has to be added to your total. Do you know who provides these services and what they charge? For a true apples to apples comparison, it has to be a full property management provider.

I'm surprised that there are not more owners in this forum who stand up for the value of their ownership. There are several very prolific and loud posters on this forum who take as many negative angles as they can to discourage any kind of ownership, retail or resale. I'm guessing its because they either have an axe to grind or they have some other profit motive such as encouraging rentals of their own units instead of ownership. It certainly isn't a good thing for any owner that these voices are not challenged more.
 

LisaRex

TUG Review Crew
TUG Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2007
Messages
6,792
Reaction score
317
Points
518
Location
'burbs of Cincinnati, OH
Resorts Owned
Used to own: WKORV-N; SVV - Bella
For the property taxes, you have cherry picked one of the lowest valued 2BR at Honua Kai. The values of 2BR at Honua Kai are in the $1.6-1.7MM range.

I simply linked to the first condo I found that had a 2 bdrm 2 bath ~1230 sq. footage. If you can provide a link to another higher valued, similar-sized condo, we can average them together. That's what the WKORV HOA does when it passes the property tax cost on to its owners; IV owners pay the same property taxes as OF owners.

WahooWah said:
Your replacement reserve estimates are still very much understated as are your assumptions on housekeeping costs.

And yet you still cannot explain WHY you think it's understated, or offer up data to support your opinion.
FYI, my housekeeping costs of $200/week was based on a simple internet search of housekeeping rates for a 2 bdrm/2 bath condo on Maui:

https://mauicleaningcare.com/services/
https://hulamaids.com/pricing/

Further data:
This 1325 sq foot 2 bdrm/2 bath owner at Honua Kai charges renters $225 a week for housekeeping. https://www.vrbo.com/821174
This 1200 sq. foot 2 bdrm/2 bath owner at Polo Beach club (a super nice condo complex in Wailea, the swankiest part of Maui) charges $175/week cleaning fee. https://www.vrbo.com/90443

Once again, this is what a private individual might expect to pay. The management team at WKORV should be able to negotiate a much better deal for their owners due to volume. Last I checked, the HOA was charging WKORV owners ~$450/week for housekeeping. Given that the average housekeeper makes $14.66/hour in Hawaii, that should pay for 30 hours of housekeeping per owner. Does that seem reasonable to you?

https://work.chron.com/average-housekeeping-wages-1481.html

Your HOA figure for Honua Kai is also low and not a true representation of the average blend for 2BR ownerships.

No it's not low. It's the actual rate for that ~1200 sf unit, which is almost the exact size as a WKORV-N unit. MFs at both WKORV and Honua Kai are based on square footage of the unit, not the valuation of the condo. Or do you not believe that it takes the same amount of time to clean a 1200 sf ocean front condo as it does a 1200 sf island view condo? Or that a 1200 sf OF unit somehow uses more water, electricity, and cable than an IV owner? Or that an OV owner uses the pool more?

https://www.hawaiirealestatesearch.com/blog/honua-kai-hoa-fees.html

The Honua Kai HOAs most certainly do not include the full property management services an owner would need if renting their unit four weeks out of every month.

HOAs go to maintaining the property to a certain standard. They're not supposed to go towards assisting owners in renting out their unit. Owners at either resort who choose to rent out their unit must do the work of advertising, fielding questions, writing contracts, collecting money, adding names to the reservation, etc. themselves, or they must hire an agent (on their own dime) to do the work. So I'm not sure what your point is here.

I'm surprised that there are not more owners in this forum who stand up for the value of their ownership. There are several very prolific and loud posters on this forum who take as many negative angles as they can to discourage any kind of ownership, retail or resale.

Whether I advise someone to own usually depends on a simple analysis of how much it costs to own vs. renting a comparable unit. That is the way that I can calculate "value." How do you calculate value of ownership?

I'm guessing its because they either have an axe to grind or they have some other profit motive such as encouraging rentals of their own units instead of ownership.

LOL. Well, I WISH I owned a rental condo at Honua Kai. Does that count?

Personally, I'm guessing that most owners know that their fees are higher than they should be, but as long as they're not being hosed too badly, as long as fees remain stable, and as long as their home resort is still beautiful, they'll just shrug it off as the cost of owning one a hotel-branded timeshare.

And FYI, that is a perfectly reasonable stance to take if you have the money to afford it. However, the question was whether the HOA was trying to hold costs down, and I'm trying to explain why the HOA isn't really doing anything but rubber stamping what the management team presents to them.

It certainly isn't a good thing for any owner that these voices are not challenged more.
Honest and respectful dialogue is always a good thing IMO. "You are wrong" is not furthering a discussion, unless you can explain WHY you think I'm wrong. You are great at offering up unsubstantiated opinions. but talk is cheap.

IMO, if any "challenging" should be done, it's that ALL owners should challenge their HOA representatives to actually do the job that they were elected to do, sham election or not, and that is to represent the owners. They should be asking questions on owner's behalf, such as, "What exactly are "Financial Services" that I see on this balance sheet, that we owners are paying over a quarter of a million dollars for? or "Given that the average housekeeper makes less than $15/hour, can we look at our contract to see what rate we're paying?"

Remember, the entire purpose of an HOA board is to provide a check-and balance to the management team, who clearly represent their (for profit) interests.
 

Ken555

TUG Review Crew: Veteran
TUG Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
14,522
Reaction score
5,638
Points
898
Location
Los Angeles
Resorts Owned
Westin Kierland
Sheraton Desert Oasis
IMO, if any "challenging" should be done, it's that ALL owners should challenge their HOA representatives to actually do the job that they were elected to do, sham election or not, and that is to represent the owners. They should be asking questions on owner's behalf, such as, "What exactly are "Financial Services" that I see on this balance sheet, that we owners are paying over a quarter of a million dollars for? or "Given that the average housekeeper makes less than $15/hour, can we look at our contract to see what rate we're paying?"

^^^THIS

More transparency would help owners understand where their money is being spent, and create more questions and problems for management. It won't happen, though we can always hope.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

Maui_ed

TUG Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
269
Reaction score
35
Points
239
Location
Pacific Northwest
Resorts Owned
WPORV, WKORV, WDW

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
I simply linked to the first condo I found that had a 2 bdrm 2 bath ~1230 sq. footage. If you can provide a link to another higher valued, similar-sized condo, we can average them together. That's what the WKORV HOA does when it passes the property tax cost on to its owners; IV owners pay the same property taxes as OF owners.





HOAs go to maintaining the property to a certain standard. They're not supposed to go towards assisting owners in renting out their unit. Owners at either resort who choose to rent out their unit must do the work of advertising, fielding questions, writing contracts, collecting money, adding names to the reservation, etc. themselves, or they must hire an agent (on their own dime) to do the work. So I'm not sure what your point is here.

I provided the average value of a 2BR at Honua Kai. The tax rate for a this category is $9.37/$1,000 of assessed value. That comes to at least $1,250 per month.

Vistana provides full reservation and concierge services for its owners (home reservations, StarOptions, SPG points, etc.). How do you propose they eliminate this expense, which you have completely excluded from your analysis?

And, yes, claiming that Vistana charges DOUBLE than what one would ordinarily have to pay is flat out WRONG and purposefully misleading (axe to grind?). You would make a great salesman at these resorts!
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
^^^THIS

More transparency would help owners understand where their money is being spent, and create more questions and problems for management. It won't happen, though we can always hope.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I certainly agree with this and LisaRex's point that all owners should challenge the decisions made by the HOA. But that should not invalidate my point that LisaRex has gone through some incredible lengths to misrepresent the value differences between owning at WKORV and comparable alternatives. THAT should also be of great concern to owners, IMO. Imagine if you were attempting to sell your property and someone who is no longer even an owner at your property and who has previously expressed his anger publicly towards the HOA of this property many, many times, spends a great deal of his free time compiling this information (inaccurately) and uses it to dissuade someone from even considering owning your property even if purchasing on the resale market. What would you think then?

Another question. If you were an owner at this property for the last ten years, would you or would you not appreciate a) that the HOA has fought heavily at a significantly high cost to fight the county of Maui for their discriminatory and vindictive property tax assessments against the Vistana owners? and b) that the HOAs have been kept relatively flat for two years running.

(BTW, I didn't even bring up the fact that timeshare properties are assessed MORE than the $9.37/$1,000 figure I provided in my previous post)
 

LisaRex

TUG Review Crew
TUG Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2007
Messages
6,792
Reaction score
317
Points
518
Location
'burbs of Cincinnati, OH
Resorts Owned
Used to own: WKORV-N; SVV - Bella
I provided the average value of a 2BR at Honua Kai. The tax rate for a this category is $9.37/$1,000 of assessed value. That comes to at least $1,250 per month.

Where did you get the averages from? I'm looking at the actual database for property taxes and am finding assessed values for 2 bdrm/2 bath 1230sf units to be between $1M to $1.6M, with the vast majority being assessed at ~$1.2M, which is about $1000/month.

http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060368&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060580
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060594&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060599&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060610&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060617&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060378&
http://qpublic9.qpublic.net/hi_maui_display.php?KEY=440140060373&

Yes, timeshares are taxed much higher than other properties. Honua Kai was originally classified as a hotel/resort, but it appears that owner-occupied units are now being classified as "Apartment" ($6.31/$1000)and non-owner occupied units are now being taxed at a brand new classification called "Short Term Rental" ($9.28/$1000).

Another question. If you were an owner at this property for the last ten years, would you or would you not appreciate a) that the HOA has fought heavily at a significantly high cost to fight the county of Maui for their discriminatory and vindictive property tax assessments against the Vistana owners? and b) that the HOAs have been kept relatively flat for two years running.

As a former owner of WKORV-N, I remain convinced that around 2008, some Starwood official did something egregious, such as having an affair with the Mayor's wife or kicking his puppy, because it was clear that Maui council was going to do everything it could, legally or not, to harm current and future SVO developments. While I honestly don't know who started the pissing contest, I wished that they'd end it already because the only people harmed in it were the owners. Do not be fooled: Every single dime spent in paying higher property taxes and/or fighting the property taxes was simply passed along to the owners.

That being said, I assume that the emergency SA that was collected a few years back in order to pay for the discriminatory and ultimately illegal retroactive assessment will soon be returned to owners and not simply absorbed by mysterious and undocumented "fees" associated with fighting it.

Vistana provides full reservation and concierge services for its owners (home reservations, StarOptions, SPG points, etc.). How do you propose they eliminate this expense, which you have completely excluded from your analysis?

This is what the SVN fees pay, which was deducted from the analysis at your suggestion.
 
Last edited:

Maui_ed

TUG Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
269
Reaction score
35
Points
239
Location
Pacific Northwest
Resorts Owned
WPORV, WKORV, WDW
That being said, I assume that the emergency SA that was collected a few years back in order to pay for the discriminatory and ultimately illegal retroactive assessment will soon be returned to owners and not simply absorbed by mysterious and undocumented "fees" associated with fighting it.
As a current owner of WKORVN, I too hope that the assessment is returned to the owners.
 

dioxide45

TUG Review Crew: Expert
TUG Member
Joined
May 20, 2006
Messages
47,374
Reaction score
18,932
Points
1,299
Location
NE Florida
Resorts Owned
Marriott Grande Vista
Marriott Harbour Lake
Sheraton Vistana Villages
Club Wyndham CWA
As a current owner of WKORVN, I too hope that the assessment is returned to the owners.
I think @LisaRex is hoping it is returned to the original owner that paid the SA, not the current owners. There are a number of people that paid it that are now no longer owners and if returned it would go back to the new owner that never paid the SA.
 

LisaRex

TUG Review Crew
TUG Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2007
Messages
6,792
Reaction score
317
Points
518
Location
'burbs of Cincinnati, OH
Resorts Owned
Used to own: WKORV-N; SVV - Bella
I think @LisaRex is hoping it is returned to the original owner that paid the SA, not the current owners.

I didn't pay the SA, even though I owned in the year that was retroactively taxed. So, yes, I absolutely hope that it's returned to whomever paid the SA.
 

vacationtime1

TUG Review Crew: Veteran
TUG Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2006
Messages
5,159
Reaction score
2,750
Points
649
Location
San Francisco
Resorts Owned
WKORV-OF (Maui)
WKV x2 (Scottsdale)
I didn't pay the SA, even though I owned in the year that was retroactively taxed. So, yes, I absolutely hope that it's returned to whomever paid the SA.

That won't happen. The Vistana-controlled HOA Board will use any tax refund to keep MF's artificially low for a couple of years to make themselves (and Vistana) look good in the process.

The excuse will be that it would be too expensive to track down each owner who paid the SA years earlier, that many owners had died, that trustees have been changed, etc.
 

Maui_ed

TUG Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2008
Messages
269
Reaction score
35
Points
239
Location
Pacific Northwest
Resorts Owned
WPORV, WKORV, WDW
I think @LisaRex is hoping it is returned to the original owner that paid the SA, not the current owners. There are a number of people that paid it that are now no longer owners and if returned it would go back to the new owner that never paid the SA.
Ah, did not read it that way initially. I owned at the time, paid the SA, and still own, so was looking at it perhaps more selfishly. I agree with the sentiment that those who paid should be the ones to whom the refund is given, if there is a refund. Not convinced there will be, though.
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
This is what the SVN fees pay, which was deducted from the analysis at your suggestion.

No, the SNV fees do not cover these expenses. They cover the I.I. membership and I would guess fees associated with StarOptions. The home resort reservation system and associated expenses are paid for through the HOAs.

I can say with nearly 100% certainty that the SA will not go back to those who originally paid for it and subsequently sold. It is a legal and administrative nightmare that would cost a lot of additional money to do otherwise, unfortunately. Just like those owners who were assessed the SA even though they never may have had use during the time period of the back-tax (2006-2008), those who paid the tax and then sold their property will not get their money back. This is just my speculation, but I'm pretty sure that a good portion of the SA will be used to pay off legal expenses for all of the separate legal battles the HOA is and has been fighting against the county for almost ten years now and anything left over will fund regular HOA expenses.
 

Ken555

TUG Review Crew: Veteran
TUG Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
14,522
Reaction score
5,638
Points
898
Location
Los Angeles
Resorts Owned
Westin Kierland
Sheraton Desert Oasis
No, the SNV fees do not cover these expenses. They cover the I.I. membership and I would guess fees associated with StarOptions. The home resort reservation system and associated expenses are paid for through the HOAs.

This is not a high cost by any means.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
This is not a high cost by any means.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Really? Because a Honua Kai owner would have to pay a property manager 20-25% of the rental proceeds for this same cost.
 

Ken555

TUG Review Crew: Veteran
TUG Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
14,522
Reaction score
5,638
Points
898
Location
Los Angeles
Resorts Owned
Westin Kierland
Sheraton Desert Oasis
Really? Because a Honua Kai owner would have to pay a property manager 20-25% of the rental proceeds for this same cost.

To be clear, my earlier statement that it is not a high cost was in reference to the owner cost of the infrastructure expense at Vistana which operates the reservation system.

I am unclear what the Honua Kai charges for renting owners units, as it's been years since I reviewed it. But, I believe it was less (and easier) than having an independent management company.

In any case I think it rather unfair to propose that we should allocate a similar amount for the Vistana reservation infrastructure as we would for an independent. That actually tells us quite a lot about your objectivity here...

And, FWIW, I'm still waiting for you to respond to the well thought out post earlier especially in regards to the cost of housekeeping services. You seem to only respond to items you want to discuss so perhaps before we continue you could scroll up and respond in more detail. Thanks.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
To be clear, my earlier statement that it is not a high cost was in reference to the owner cost of the infrastructure expense at Vistana which operates the reservation system.

I am unclear what the Honua Kai charges for renting owners units, as it's been years since I reviewed it. But, I believe it was less (and easier) than having an independent management company.

In any case I think it rather unfair to propose that we should allocate a similar amount for the Vistana reservation infrastructure as we would for an independent. That actually tells us quite a lot about your objectivity here...

And, FWIW, I'm still waiting for you to respond to the well thought out post earlier especially in regards to the cost of housekeeping services. You seem to only respond to items you want to discuss so perhaps before we continue you could scroll up and respond in more detail. Thanks.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Your contributions to the discussion so far have been conjecture, uninformed opinions, baseless accusations and a general sense of entitlement. I have not seen you present a single fact or a shred of thoughtful analysis to this topic.
 

DeniseM

Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
57,671
Reaction score
9,091
Points
1,849
Resorts Owned
WKORV, WKV, 2-SDO, 4-Kauai Beach Villas, Island Park Village (Yellowstone), Hyatt High Sierra, Dolphin's Cove (Anaheim)
It's interesting to hear the corporate side of the picture, because I thought Vistana had a strict policy against employees participating in TUG. Maybe that was a Starwood policy, and Vistana has approved your participation?
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
It's interesting to hear the corporate side of the picture, because I thought Vistana had a strict policy against employees participating in TUG. Maybe that was a Starwood policy, and Vistana has approved your participation?

Interesting perspective from someone who profits from renting out their StarOptions for profit and discourages people from owning at WKORV directly and renting instead. But I have never been an employee of Vistana or Starwood ever.
 

DeniseM

Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
57,671
Reaction score
9,091
Points
1,849
Resorts Owned
WKORV, WKV, 2-SDO, 4-Kauai Beach Villas, Island Park Village (Yellowstone), Hyatt High Sierra, Dolphin's Cove (Anaheim)
WaHooWah - I know you are new here, but many, many people on TUG rent their timeshares for a profit - no shocker there.

This is the deal: It's not a good value to buy from the developer, because developer purchases include huge profit margins and fat commissions for the sales people. That is the majority view on TUG - on all forums/all systems. So anytime a noobie shows up with a developer purchase, we advise them to rescind, do their research, and buy resale, if they decide that buying is the right choice for them. However, there are many people who should not buy, for a variety of reasons.
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
WaHooWah - I know you are new here, but many, many people on TUG rent their timeshares for a profit - no shocker there.

This is the deal: It's not a good value to buy from the developer, because developer purchases include huge profit margins and fat commissions for the sales people. That is the majority view on TUG - on all forums/all systems. So anytime a noobie shows up with a developer purchase, we advise them to rescind, do their research, and buy resale, if they decide that buying is the right choice for them. However, there are many people who should not buy, for a variety of reasons.

I totally agree with everything that you said above, except for that fact that I am new here or a noob. I joined this forum in 2010 and have read it off and on over the last eight years. I think it is important for people who are contemplating purchasing to understand your first statement, that many people on TUG rent their timeshares for profit. They should contemplate how that fact might bias the poster's advice and recommendations on whether or not to make a purchase.
 

DeniseM

Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
57,671
Reaction score
9,091
Points
1,849
Resorts Owned
WKORV, WKV, 2-SDO, 4-Kauai Beach Villas, Island Park Village (Yellowstone), Hyatt High Sierra, Dolphin's Cove (Anaheim)
WahooWah - Since you have years of experience on TUG, you've probably noticed that your pro-management approach is out of step with TUG. Please tell us why you promote buying a timeshare, and defend the management company, so we can understand where you are coming from.

I don't know too many people who know 3 board members, so you obviously have a close connection with the Maui resorts. We'd love to know what experience you have, to back up your strong opinions.
 

WahooWah

Guest
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
120
Reaction score
55
Points
188
I choose not to provide much information other than what I have provided. I do not consider myself to be pro-management. That is not my stance at all. All I have done is poke holes into the incomplete analysis of someone who, from what I can discern from their posting history, has an axe to grind with WKORV in particular, and encourage other owners to raise their voices and defend their ownership from posters whose bias purposefully and unjustifiably devalue their property. If you feel more comfortable with assigning labels, I guess you could say that I am pro-owner, not pro-management. I do appreciate the work that the board is doing to fight the illegal actions of the Maui County Council (for a number of other reasons unrelated to this thread), I am ecstatic for ALL owners of Maui timeshare that these efforts appear to be paying off and I find it encouraging for WKORV owners that the HOA fees have been more or less flat for the last three years.

I can't control how people feel if my opinions and facts contradict the narrative of certain posters on this board.
 

DeniseM

Moderator
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
57,671
Reaction score
9,091
Points
1,849
Resorts Owned
WKORV, WKV, 2-SDO, 4-Kauai Beach Villas, Island Park Village (Yellowstone), Hyatt High Sierra, Dolphin's Cove (Anaheim)
encourage other owners to raise their voices and defend their ownership

When someone comes to TUG, and wants us to "raise our voices and defend our ownership," it's usually because they are sales people. It will be interesting to see who you turn out to be.

Since you are located in Lahaina, I'm guessing sales, or perhaps a local reseller, or since you know 3 board members, maybe lower management. Aloha!
 
Last edited:
Top