My resort is Silverwoods at Treasure Lake. It has a HOA but is managed by Crown Resorts. So, who would you say makes the final decisions in a deed back? (If they will even take it back)
Unless the HOA is comprised primarily or solely of
stooges hand picked representatives of the resort developer (which is generally only true within the "chains", e.g., Legacy Vacation Club (formerly known as Celebrity Resorts), Wyndham, etc., then it is the owner-elected BoD / HOA that makes any and all decisions and policies regarding acceptance of "deedbacks".
At any and all "independent" facilities (i.e., those not associated with any "chain"), it is
solely the owner-elected BoD / HOA that makes any and all such decisions.
Fwiw, I cannot envision a scenario where a contracted (...and always replaceable) management company (and / or its' on site representative, the property manager) would have
any authority or say in the matter whatsoever. Remember, at independent facilities the management company (and it's' on site property manager) are, in effect, paid
employees of all the timeshare owners there. The mgt. company is hired by (and can be fired by) the BoD / HOA that represents all the owners there.
In other words, the tail does not wag the dog --- the dog wags the tail. You want to reach the President of the HOA --- anything else is just a "conversation".