High Line is just about an every trip thing for us, 2-3 times a year. Very enjoyable, especially early.
Let's put things in perspective. First, this is not "raving." This is enjoying a very nice experience in an included timeshare lounge. I don't know of many places that have this. Nice breakfast when they have the quiches. Espresso and coffee. Reasonable hot items in the evening (no, not world class), nice cheese and fruit. Guac!
Brooklyn Lager is a mid-tier beer. The wine (the red, anyway, as I don't drink white) is also a medium tier.
It is certainly not comparable to most Hilton international ELs or most international Business and First airline lounges. But that's not what it's trying to be. If that's your standard of comparison then, yeah, it won't look as good.
But it still beats the snot out of the midtown EL