I've owned 2 weeks at MGR since 2003 and we've always, always gotten our requests honored... UNTIL about 2 years ago. I don't know what happened, but they never give us what we've requested anymore, even thought we 1) book our week a year in advance, 2) fill out the villa preference form immediately upon receiving it, and 3) arrive around 11:00 a.m.
So for the past 2 years after getting a not-desired villa I end up asking the front desk if anything is available in the building or buildings we prefer. Usually there is, but we have to wait hours before the room is clean and available. We are going in 3 weeks using an AC and my expectations are low of getting any of my requests honored, even though it's off-season.
Want to hear something else I found interesting? We booked a guestroom to stay in our 1st night (before our week-long stay in a 2BR). I got a villa preference request form for that first night, but the only views that were available to choose from were lake view and golf view. Then when I got the villa preference request form for the week-long stay, in addition to lake and golf views, pool view was an option. I guess they don't give guestroom customers the option of a pool view (?).
My husband and I are going down a day early and will stay the first night in a guestroom, then my son will be joining us for the week when we move into a 2BR, and they had better not link our reservations and try to put us in the same villa and then refuse to clean the guestroom after we check out, like they tried to do to us last time. This time I requested a lake view for the first night, and a pool view (followed by a golf view as my 2nd choice) for the week-long stay. It will be interesting to see how they handle it this time.