Perfect timing for the revival of this subject, as we just returned this morning from our stay at River Island. I no longer need to dig up the previous threads to comment.
I want to preface my statements by stressing how much we enjoyed our 10 days at this fabulous resort. A family with youngens such as ours would never need to leave the resort to find entertainment. The warm pools, staff, restaurants, ammenties- all superb. The 2BR unit at River Island was exceptional. However, we also had a 2BR at West Village and actually preferred the large patio at that location (less hotel feeling.) What a fantastic upgrade job they did to West Village.
Both of my sons said it was their favorite resort thus far, and we go to many. My 19 yr old brought a friend and they met many others by the beach and pool.
Ah, but the SMELL . . . We couldn't smell it at West Village. However, River Island was almost unbearable, especially when the wind picked up at night. We live in the country so I consider our tolerance pretty high. I told my husband and the kids that it was our close proximity to Animal Kingdom and I can't believe they bought it- the thought of smelling animals seems less offensive than a sewage plant.
Again, our stay was one of our very best vacations ever and I would not hesitate to return to West Village. The many OLCC owners here at TUG have much to be proud of.
Jana