Hi Steel5Rings,
We stayed at Broadway Plantations this past summer. We had a very nice time; it's a very nice resort.
A couple of things though.
The pool area, even though it has been expanded with a second pool and a lazy man river, seemed too small for us. Not because we are big people

, but because it was very crowded. One could always find a pool chair, that wasn't the problem. The issue was the pools themselves: too small for all of the people using them. It was hard not to bump into other people.
Broadway Plantations is in the midst of a very large expansion, and according to the plans that are posted in the lobby, the pool area is as big as it's going to get. I think 7 or 8 more buildings are planned, and I can't imagine how this one pool area is going to handle all that traffic. Now, I didn't ask about any future pool plans, but the map showed just the one area, so I have to assume what you see is what you get. I could be wrong, though.
The reason the pool area is so important is that you have to drive to get to a beach. Added to that, the surf at Myrtle Beach is very strong. So, if you have small kids, want to stay close to your unit, you want the pool. And so does everyone else, it turns out.
Another issue for us was the bar area. Believe it or not, the bar (which serves food) closes at about 6pm. And on Sundays, it does not serve alcohol. I'll repeat that. The bar does NOT serve alcohol on Sundays.
We're not heavy drinkers by any stretch. But, on the Friday we arrived, after ten hours on the road, all we wanted to do was stretch out at the pool, tropical drink in hand, maybe some burgers, and relax. Only to find the bar/restaurant closed an hour before!! Sunday morning, we thought a refreshing mimosa would be nice poolside. Wrong again. Bar/restaurant open, no spirits.
The pool bar area is the resort's only option for food. The gift shop in the lobby is tiny, so there isn't even the option of picking up something there to bring back to the unit to heat up. When the bar/restaurant is closed, one must get in the car and go somewhere else. Obviously, we didn't know this before hand.
On the positive side. The resort staff was very, very friendly. The grounds are beautiful. And, in my opinion, will only get nicer as the resort grows. Right now there's no escaping the construction, but once it is done, I'm sure BP will be beautiful. The resort reminds me of a small Vistana Resort. The buildings (which are all very nice) are similar in style to Vistana Resort. The grounds are very nice to walk around. The ponds are populated with ducks, fish, turtles. There's a cute little (free) mini golf area. There also are some tennis courts. The lobby is small, but very nicely decorated, with a large fireplace. The concierge desk is very helpful. There is no internet access in the rooms. But there is wifi in the lobby. There's one computer in the lobby, but you have to wait your turn. Many people (including us) just brought the laptop to the lobby (which is right next to the pool) and accessed the internet that way.
As noted above, Sheraton Broadway Plantation is not located on the ocean.
That wasn't a big issue for us. Getting to the beach took all of five minutes.
BP IS located next to the Broadway on the Beach complex. On Tuesday nights, we could clearly see the fireworks from our room.
One other thing you should know about, if you go to the public beach areas, there are no bathroom facilities. You'll find those at the State Beach, which is about a 20 minute drive away. You will pay a fee to use that beach.
We did both (public and State), and enjoyed both very much.
We also did the owners update. And we discovered, much to our surprise, that the developer price for Broadway Plantation is the same as Vistana Villages in Orlando. Be aware though, the BP is non-mandatory, meaning, if you buy on the resale market, you do not get Star Options, which allow you to use the SVO system. You'll only get those at BP by buying from Starwood directly. If you do that, disregard the bargain basement prices you see on Ebay. I think that, more than the beach issue, is why BP is so affordable on Ebay and elsewhere.
Bottom line, we enjoyed our time at Myrtle Beach at Broadway Plantation.
We wish the pool and bar situation was different, but it is still a nice place to visit and vacation.
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to ask.
bward