Hmmm, my husband has our Entertainment book at work, so I'm not sure which Williamsburg restaurants are listed...here are the restaurants we frequent:
Shacklefords II at Monticello Marketplace
Sal's by Victor at the Williamsburg Shopping Center (food is great, service can be so-so)
The Fat Canary at Merchant's Square (can get pricey)
The Trellis at Merchant's Square (dinner is great, but $$$ and plan to dress up, lunch is less expensive and more casual)
Berrett's at Merchant's Square
Aroma's on Prince George Street in Colonial Williamsburg
Kyoto on Route 60
The Aberdeen Barn on Route 60
Eagle's at Kingsmill
Nick's Riverwalk Restaurant in Yorktown
Doraldo's at the Kingsmill Shops
Ukrop's Grill and take out at Monticello Marketplace
The Melting Pot in Newport News ($$$, but AWESOME food)
The County Grill (awesome BBQ) in southern York County
Pierce's Pitt BBQ off Rochamnbeau
Places we don't care for:
The Sportsman's Grill at Kingsmill Festival Marketplace
The Whaling Company (near Kingsmill)
Season's at Merchant's Square
Red, Hot, and Blue
Hope that helps; feel free to email me with questions.
Jeni