You clearly made the correct decision for your circumstances, but for me, W. 57th is beyond my budget, so that is not an option. I more than doubled my money by selling back my HCNY contracts, which was very nice, but keeping them could have made economic sense to me if it were not for the fact that I have almost no chance to use much more of the membership, given my cancer diagnosis. I think that the decision to sell (or trade) is a personal one based on one's individual circumstances, which is why is disagree with a blanket "take the money and run" statement, which presumes that the ownership has less value than the amount gained by selling the membership back. For some people, it clearly is but not for everyone.